Bahrain: The Revolution Forgotten

Bahrain is the revolution everyone forgot about, but she is still going strong.




A word on the situation in Bahrain:

Unlike other countries in the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC), the tiny island of Bahrain is a unique situation in the following ways:

  • Bahrain has had a strong national identity for close to a thousand years
  • Bahrain is majority Shia'
  • Compared to other GCC states, Bahrain has a relatively low number of foreign migrant workers in the labor pool, around ~58% (as opposed to a place like UAE at 90%+)


This means that there is a disillusioned nationalist indigenous solid workforce from which to launch a revolution. Whereas in a place like the UAE suffers from incredible income inequality, exploitation of enslaved labor, and severe political repression, the different languages, nationalities, races, etc of the migrant labor force impedes any united effort to rise up. Bahrain is different in this regard.

Another issue worth mentioning, though it turns my stomach a bit, is that Bahrain is majority Shia' but ruled over by a Sunni family. This leads to sectarian tension, but moreso deepens the suspicions of the people towards the ruling family, which is on good terms with other GCC Sunni kings, and of the ruling family towards the people, who they would accuse as being in he pocket of new GCC favorite great Shaytan: Iran.

There are two major geostrategic interests in Bahrain: it is an hour's drive from the Eastern oil fields in Saudi Arabia and there is a giant US Navy base of operations (USN CENTCOM) and the 5th fleet is stationed there.



Under these conditions, the GCC was very aggressive when it came to helping the ruling Khalifa family crush the revolution. They sent in troops, many of them not even Arab, to shoot unarmed peaceful protestors. They demolished the square where the people had been meeting to protest. They imprisoned thousands of Bahrainis and dumped dead tortured bodies in the streets. They shut down phone service and scoped out facebook looking for protesters to arrest. Even more shocking, there was only one foreign news crew in Bahrain at the time this happened. This is a good documentary about Bahrain recently aired on Al-Jazeera English, taken during this time.



I went to a speech about the "Arab Spring" at the LSE last year and stood up to ask why Bahrain was never talked about. Why is it that Bahrain is unworthy of mention? I think this is why it's important to accept that on one hand, yes, the Arab Spring is legitimate and comes from people's desires to shrug off the yoke of oppression. On the other hand, it is a media narrative that has been utilized to push neoliberal policies in the region. This media narrative is subject to power interests. This explains very well why Bahrain has been "forgotten" ... unlike the Arab states in the maghreb, stability stakes are higher in Bahrain. The GCC is very involved in the discourse and financial work taking place with the Arab Spring throughout the Arabic-speaking world, but when it comes to something so close to their sphere of influence, just an hour drive from Saudi oil fields, they are quick to strike hard and quietly. And the West is quick to keep the silence.

There is currently a human rights activist who is on hunger strike in Bahrain. Today is his 59th day. His name is Abdulhadi al-Khawaja and he was sentenced to life in prison for organizing protests. He has diabetes and has recently been forced onto intravenous feeding. As a dual citizen of Denmark, where he spent decades in political exile, there is speculation that Bahrain will let him go there. This is a recent trend (hunger strikers) and the solution seems to be a spatial fix, shipping the starving prisoners elsewhere. People are still killed and imprisoned in Bahrain on a weekly basis. Yet no one really has a clear idea what is going on - like in all the GCC countries (there was also an uprising in Saudi) it seems very important to the Powers That Be that the message is heavily controlled.

Either way, the Bahraini revolution keeps trudging along, over a year in the making, with very few listening. Bless their hearts. I hope you learned something. Thank you.

Discussion of Bahrain: The Revolution Forgotten on tHE r H i z z o n E:

#1
The only real sectarian tensions between Shi'a and Sunni are from foreigners and the elite who perceive Iranian conspiracies behind the uprising. The actual population has demonstrated almost unanimous Sunni-Shi'a solidarity as far as I know.

You didn't mention the American naval base in Bahrain, which is very important to the Iraqi mission.
#2

babyfinland posted:
You didn't mention the American naval base in Bahrain, which is very important to the Iraqi mission.



discipline posted:
the 5th fleet is stationed there.


#3
Welp there u go

A cool thing about the uprising in Bahrain, like in Yemen, is the very strong presence of women.

For example: http://www.google.com/hostednews/afp/article/ALeqM5h7L-kFaWnBPm0xsqq_EcPPeaPuXQ?docId=CNG.508d4f8e1d7a5d61d2eb3a01316ab8ed.1d1
#4
Yemen Femen
#5
Interview with a spokesperson from the Coalition of February 14th Youth: http://www.jadaliyya.com/pages/index/4777/bahrains-revolutionaries-speak_an-exclusive-interv

The first and foremost goal that revolutionaries are struggling for is the liberation of our land from Saudi occupation and the overthrow of the Al-Khalifa regime, which has lost its popular and constitutional legitimacy. Once that is achieved, the people can choose their own destiny and choose the political and economic system that meets their ambitions and aspirations. We will not under any circumstance accept a compromise with this bloody regime that continues to violate our human rights. We are determined to liberate our precious homeland from dictatorship, and build a nation of justice, dignity, and equality for all its citizens.



The coalition’s objectives and demands, as they have been outlined in the Pearl Charter, are as follows:

Overthrowing the tribal Al-Khalifa regime, which has lost its legitimacy, and bringing its heads and officials to trial, including Hamad the dictator, for the crimes against humanity that they have committed against our people.

Ensuring the people's right to self-determination and ability to choose the political system that meets their ambitions and aspirations.

Dismantling the current state security agencies and rebuilding them along modern standards that ensure safety and security for all citizens.

Forming an independent and fair judiciary.

Reinforcing the principle of separation of powers (Legislative, Executive and Judiciary).

Maintaining national unity, preserving the social fabric, promoting justice and equality, and prohibiting any form of discrimination against citizens.

Finding a realistic and fair solution to the problem of systematic political naturalization that has been created by the regime to change the original identity and demographics of the country.

Preserving the Islamic and Arab identity of Bahrain.

Forming a national body to oversee the election of a Constituent Assembly that will write a new constitution for the country after the fall of the Al-Khalifa regime.

Ensuring the fair distribution of wealth while protecting national resources and gains for future generations.

#6
From what I can tell the protestors will be as successful at overthrowing their government as those in Libya, Egypt, Yemen and eventually Syria, but there's one thing that could ruin everything.

http://www.usnews.com/news/world/articles/2012/04/07/bahrain-hosts-warplane-drills-with-us-arab-allies

MANAMA, Bahrain (AP) — Bahrain's military says the U.S. and eight other countries are taking part in the Gulf nation's largest air force exercises in more than two decades.

The official Bahrain News Agency says at least 100 warplanes will join the drills Sunday, which come amid heightened Western pressures on Iran over Tehran's nuclear program.

Bahrain also is home to the U.S. Navy's 5th Fleet. Bahrain says the aerial maneuvers are its biggest since 1988 and include Arab allies, Turkey, Pakistan and the U.S.

Bahrain's Sunni monarchy is facing a nearly 14-month-old uprising by the kingdom's majority Shiites, who are seeking a greater political voice.



babyfinland posted:
The only real sectarian tensions between Shi'a and Sunni are from foreigners and the elite who perceive Iranian conspiracies behind the uprising. The actual population has demonstrated almost unanimous Sunni-Shi'a solidarity as far as I know.



The Iraqi Shiites and Sunnis fought against Iran during the Iraq-Iran war but that didn't stop them tearing each other apart during the recent conflict. If an attack on Iran turns into a regional war Bahrain looks like ground zero. The protestors should be focused on getting those militaries the hell away from their country and try to become that region's Switzerland.

#7
By gum internationalist you've done it again!
#8
why the f*ck do people try to make weirdo european analogies to countries. Bahrain should be the Gulf's Switzerland. Syria can become the Arab Denmark. Fart so hard my balls explode
#9
Israel is West Asia's Great Britain.
#10
[account deactivated]
#11
it pains me to do it, and upvote an internationalist post, thereby changing his rep from 44, but his posting is just so impeccable that i'm compelled and unable to resist furiously mashing the upvote button when i see one of his posts
#12

AmericanNazbro posted:
it pains me to do it, and upvote an internationalist post, thereby changing his rep from 44, but his posting is just so impeccable that i'm compelled and unable to resist furiously mashing the upvote button when i see one of his posts

#13
Bahrain: The Tense Passive
#14
Lol
#15
REAL FOTAGE FROM BAHRAIN L@@K
#16

discipline posted:
They sent in troops, many of them not even Arab, to shoot unarmed peaceful protestors.



does this impyl that that troops were foreign nationals?

#17
[account deactivated]
#18
[account deactivated]
#19
do you think that's because the GCC's internal (presumably majority-arab) security forces are unwilling to use force on other arabs, so they need foreign mercenaries to do it?
#20

discipline posted:
migration patterns & policies in the gulf are fascinating and really intense (my dissertation supervisor is one of the big names in this field) so if anyone is interested I might make another thread when I'm done with this paper



that would be cool

#21
[account deactivated]
#22
[account deactivated]
#23
i guess what i'm wondering is what the significance of non-arab troops being used is as far as these uprisings go, since you mentioned it
#24
[account deactivated]
#25
gotcha, i was thinking you were mentioning it because of some immediate effect on the shape of the uprising given the context of bahrain's strong national identity which you outlined.
#26
[account deactivated]
#27

discipline posted:
I apologize if my brain leaks everywhere sometimes

same but adult diapers for sexual reasons.

-placeholder for image-

#28
[account deactivated]
#29
britain and japan should apply for membership
#30

shennong posted:
do you think that's because the GCC's internal (presumably majority-arab) security forces are unwilling to use force on other arabs, so they need foreign mercenaries to do it?



thats adorable

#31

discipline posted:
the only arabs I ever heard say nasty things about palestinians were khaleej.



clearly you didnt spend enough time in Jordan

#32

babyfinland posted:

shennong posted:
do you think that's because the GCC's internal (presumably majority-arab) security forces are unwilling to use force on other arabs, so they need foreign mercenaries to do it?

thats adorable



maybe i am stupendously ignorant... or MAYBE i am chosing to see the latent rahma in the saudi armed forces for their fellow children of ishmael

#33

shennong posted:

babyfinland posted:

shennong posted:
do you think that's because the GCC's internal (presumably majority-arab) security forces are unwilling to use force on other arabs, so they need foreign mercenaries to do it?

thats adorable

maybe i am stupendously ignorant... or MAYBE i am chosing to see the latent rahma in the saudi armed forces for their fellow children of ishmael



hehe

#34

They sent in troops, many of them not even Arab, to shoot unarmed peaceful protestors.



who were the non arab troops? i'm curious about this

#35

Ironicwarcriminal posted:

They sent in troops, many of them not even Arab, to shoot unarmed peaceful protestors.

who were the non arab troops? i'm curious about this



read the thread

#36

discipline posted:
yes, many police and other security services, including the GCC's peninsula shield force (دِرْعُ الجَزيرَة‎) that so famously helped to quash the uprising, in the gulf are not khaleeji or even arab, they are generally south asian



whoops, missed this. are they the equivalent of like, Gurkha batallions or are they mercenaries or are they just normal troops in the gulf countries militaries.

really weird i didn't know that at all but i guess the us military gives citizenship to like Nicaragua who join up or whatever

#37

shennong posted:
maybe i am stupendously ignorant... or MAYBE i am chosing to see the latent rahma in the saudi armed forces for their fellow children of ishmael


Kind of like how the empathy of Western police for their fellow humans leads to them treating civilians with the utmost respect.

#38

littlegreenpills posted:
britain and japan should apply for membership



speaking of which bf please return to the prince charles av

#39
Fuck the metropolitan police
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/apr/18/bahrain-formula-one-yates-safety

#40
[account deactivated]
Care to share your thoughts? Sign up for tHE r H i z z o n E and Post your heart out, baby!