littlegreenpills posted:enforcement priorities need to be set somehow so that prostitutes are the ones who decide who to prioritize and pursue.
Then make it easier to go after the violent and abusive clients? Criminalization isn't going to help that you know.
ilmdge posted:Sounds wrong, nordic models can actually report violence against them without incriminating themselves so it should decrease violence
i mean yeah thats the idea but the thing i vaguely remember was sort of like "well even in spite of this, for some reason violence against women is increasing". maybe something like, pimps being illegal means more pressure on the prostitutes who still rely on them for money even though in theory they can call the cops "without repercussions". this isn't what i remember finding originally, but it was making similar points so it probably cited similar things, and i have no idea how valid any of it is.
MadMedico posted:littlegreenpills posted:enforcement priorities need to be set somehow so that prostitutes are the ones who decide who to prioritize and pursue.
Then make it easier to go after the violent and abusive clients? Criminalization isn't going to help that you know.
it is making it easier to go after violent and abusive clients, by criminalizing them and decriminalizing the selling of sex. And if violence against women is increasing, that doesn't just Beep Borp Computed From Policy Change. there are a multitude of factors besides whether or not degenerate perverts have some sort of punitive consequence hanging over their head
Crow posted:it is making it easier to go after violent and abusive clients, by criminalizing them and decriminalizing the selling of sex. And if violence against women is increasing, that doesn't just Beep Borp Computed From Policy Change. there are a multitude of factors besides whether or not degenerate perverts have some sort of punitive consequence hanging over their head
in the short term im pretty sure any sort of regularity in the response to the imposition of similar policies is basically totally contingent on the cultural reaction etc. i would think. what sorts of collective directed actions or other policy interventions do you think would the most effective at working along with nordic-model style prostitution legislation to see the best results? additional support to women's shelters? probably something wrt law enforcement procedures i guess?
c_man posted:Crow posted:it is making it easier to go after violent and abusive clients, by criminalizing them and decriminalizing the selling of sex. And if violence against women is increasing, that doesn't just Beep Borp Computed From Policy Change. there are a multitude of factors besides whether or not degenerate perverts have some sort of punitive consequence hanging over their head
in the short term im pretty sure any sort of regularity in the response to the imposition of similar policies is basically totally contingent on the cultural reaction etc. i would think. what sorts of collective directed actions or other policy interventions do you think would the most effective at working along with nordic-model style prostitution legislation to see the best results? additional support to women's shelters? probably something wrt law enforcement procedures i guess?
How about a program to reimburse sex workers for lost income? That definatley would stop them from having sex with people for money and would do more than the preferred method of social media integrated police stings.
littlegreenpills posted:the point of nordic models is to put a weapon into prostitutes hands.
And obviously they want to deprive themselves of their own livelihood and make their jobs much more dangerous?
daddyholes posted:Why don't you tell me what they want.
I'm not asking you too, did you know there's this thing called social media, where sex workers can communicate and you can hear from their perspectives rather than from cops, christian ngos, neoliberal imperialists, and ill informed politicians parroting garbage statistics (90% of prostitutes are controlled by pimps).
There are also good human rights organizations as well.
http://www.redumbrellaproject.org/about/
MadMedico posted:I'm not asking you too, did you know there's this thing called social media, where sex workers can communicate and you can hear from their perspectives rather than from cops, christian ngos, neoliberal imperialists, and ill informed politicians parroting garbage statistics (90% of prostitutes are controlled by pimps).
There are also good human rights organizations as well.
http://www.redumbrellaproject.org/about/
Yeah let me just click that link and also the link for facebook.com so I can learn about the sex trade.
postposting posted:wait, wtf is "social media"???????
oh, you'll find it. When you do, please share your favorite Twitter accts of all the Romanian girls who are shipped in to fuck for nearly free while bougie German/Dutch sex worker lobbyists can feel righteous.
Senorah posted:You see, with legalization all johns finally start paying correctly, stop demanding trafficked people to undercut prices
If that were true then you'd have tons well off middle class guys going to sketchy truck stops and trading meth for a handjob from a lot lizard because it's cheaper rather than hiring an upscale escort from from the internet because it would be cheaper.
Also violence against sex workers still occurs under the Nordic Model
http://www.mamacash.org/news/rose-alliance-board-member-petite-jasmine-murdered/
daddyholes posted:MM If I were you i'd can it before one of the mods trains you to conec's house. Just saying.
if that happens then i dont get why people like iwc or grumblefish who are much worse get a free pass
MadMedico posted:Senorah posted:You see, with legalization all johns finally start paying correctly, stop demanding trafficked people to undercut prices
If that were true then you'd have tons well off middle class guys going to sketchy truck stops and trading meth for a handjob from a lot lizard because it's cheaper rather than hiring an upscale escort from from the internet because it would be cheaper.
Also violence against sex workers still occurs under the Nordic Model
http://www.mamacash.org/news/rose-alliance-board-member-petite-jasmine-murdered/
congrats, fuckboy. none of this post means anything. but thanks for admitting that johns are disgusting animals that can't be tamed by legalization OR criminalization.
Senorah posted:MadMedico posted:Senorah posted:You see, with legalization all johns finally start paying correctly, stop demanding trafficked people to undercut prices
If that were true then you'd have tons well off middle class guys going to sketchy truck stops and trading meth for a handjob from a lot lizard because it's cheaper rather than hiring an upscale escort from from the internet because it would be cheaper.
Also violence against sex workers still occurs under the Nordic Model
http://www.mamacash.org/news/rose-alliance-board-member-petite-jasmine-murdered/congrats, fuckboy. none of this post means anything. but thanks for admitting that johns are disgusting animals that can't be tamed by legalization OR criminalization.
lol owned
MadMedico posted:Also when the only other career option is staying working on some muddy tuber farm in a remote village in Bulgaria where half the population is goats, a woman might make a rational decision to move to Germany or the Netherlands and sell sex to tourists, especially when she would make more in a week than she would ever see in her lifetime in her home country.
yes, well, you're also a racist, we get it
MadMedico posted:Also when the only other career option is staying working on some muddy tuber farm
freedom and democracy. capitalist riches.
Senorah posted:MadMedico posted:
Senorah posted:
You see, with legalization all johns finally start paying correctly, stop demanding trafficked people to undercut prices
If that were true then you'd have tons well off middle class guys going to sketchy truck stops and trading meth for a handjob from a lot lizard because it's cheaper rather than hiring an upscale escort from from the internet because it would be cheaper.
Also violence against sex workers still occurs under the Nordic Model
http://www.mamacash.org/news/rose-alliance-board-member-petite-jasmine-murdered/
congrats, fuckboy. none of this post means anything. but thanks for admitting that johns are disgusting animals that can't be tamed by legalization OR criminalization.
So you think rape and violence committed against sex workers is just an "occupational hazard"?
MadMedico posted:So you think rape and violence committed against sex workers is just an "occupational hazard"?
no, that's you. *you* think beatings, rape, and wage theft are acceptable risks for people to encounter during a statistically significant portion of their labor. and that sex workers should bear entire weight of the "exchange of goods" on their own. it's you. you're the fuckboy.