#1



As per Crow's suggestion feel free to post anything hilariously dumb even if it's not from our good friends at the Something Awful Forums.

Much as sweatshop conditions are deplorable, the people who work in them aren't (usually) slaves. They come because despite how hard the work is and how modest the wage, it's better than their other options. You don't just see this in China. For all the bad faith and sheer rapacious greed on the part of the factory bosses and foreign investors, sweatshop workers get a better deal than they would back in their home towns.

Companies like Foxconn are deplored in the Western world, but they have trained, employed, and (relatively) enriched literally millions of young Chinese women from the rural countryside. Think about what life means for a teenage girl in a tiny village in Hebei. Wouldn't assembling iPads for 12 hours a day actually seem a lot better?

Now, is it shitty? Yeah. And it could be better, I don't think anyone would disagree or say that trying to improve working conditions in 3rd world factories is bad. But just as much as factories go to those countries for a reason, the people who come to the factories go there for a reason too. It's an unfortunate truth that the industrial world went through exactly the same trials and tribulations a hundred years ago. Maybe it doesn't have to be like this, but the way it is is better for the locals than they way it was. Hopefully when this process has played out everywhere it will be over for good.

Edited by noavbazzer ()

#2

I think this is a neat example, as these sort of businesses never seem to be mentioned when people are discussing socialism. It seems that everyone is still in a Victorian mindset, imagining top-hatted capitalists grinding the faces of the poor in vast steel mills and coal mines. There's certainly a case for having popular control over big important industries like these, as happens in a lot of European countries.

Full central control is a different matter entirely. Say you want to put together a gypsy jazz band in your hometime. Get a few guys in on it, ring that bar you know, sort something for Friday night, five bills a head on the door and split it four ways. Done. No one has ever explained to me how the Central Bureau of Cultural Affairs is supposed to calculate the prevailing demand for experimental jam bands in North Platte, Nebraska. Price signals have their uses, let's not forget.

#3
#4
#5

Im surprised how many people are citing lf for changing their political views. Theres some value in theecho chamber of a politically tuned message biard to normalize a political view. Im also surprised how many people identify as communist. Its a shame they closed lf. I wish itd be reborn.

(USER WAS PUT ON PROBATION FOR THIS POST)

#6
[account deactivated]
#7
http://forums.somethingawful.com/showthread.php?noseen=0&threadid=3461000&pagenumber=4#post399750842
#8
it haunts me that i probably turned like a hundred little kids into obnoxious trots via lf
#9
the "stalin" heard round the world
#10
this beliefs thread is a fucking gold mine

I was already "pretty LF" when I started posting in that forum (which I miss terribly). It was a great source of information and critique with some really funny and well read posters. It went to shit when FYAD were given carte blanche to go in a fuck things up and it never really recovered. Some argue it was dead before that, but the Aus and UK threads were always great reading for whimsy or hard-hitting critique depending on the news cycle.

A friend of mine read LF because I recommended it as being funny and he wanted some info on US prisons (that thread was so fucking depressing, but it was amazing). He liked the humour and kept reading LF for a couple of years. A lot of stuff resonated with him to the point that when he finished his medicine degree he signed up for Doctors Without Borders and has been doing that for three years now. LF directly contributed to some good decisions by people by providing the often ignored gay Muslim Maoist/third-worldist perspective that is often ignored in mainstream forums.

#11

If you followed LF, then you probably remember that there was a thread in which T-Paine and friends celebrated the deaths of American soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan. I actually stopped reading LF when they yukked it up about a friend of mine whose body I had helped to recover two days prior. Trying to convince people in the Army to be more socially conscious is like trying to convince LF'ers that not all soldiers are murderous troglodytes. You might mildly influence the opinions of one or two, but most likely you'll just get retard dogpiled by people whose viewpoints are already set in stone, facts be damned.



this guy actually wrote me a hand-written letter from afghanistan when he was stationed there

#12

A friend of mine read LF because I recommended it as being funny and he wanted some info on US prisons (that thread was so fucking depressing, but it was amazing). He liked the humour and kept reading LF for a couple of years. A lot of stuff resonated with him to the point that when he finished his medicine degree he signed up for Doctors Without Borders and has been doing that for three years now. LF directly contributed to some good decisions by people by providing the often ignored gay Muslim Maoist/third-worldist perspective that is often ignored in mainstream forums.



ahahahhaha thats amazing. we did it, y'all.

#13
[account deactivated]
#14

I've pretty much always been left wing. My biggest ideological struggle has been deciding whether or not it's best to characterize my beliefs as anarcho-syndicalist or nonrevolutionary socialist.

#15
[account deactivated]
#16
nonrevolutionary socialist is how you characterize, I think, every member of this forum
#17

-Lurking in LF and being attacked like a dead cow thrown into a pond full of piranhas on some of the occasions that I posted was a great experience. I have to give a lot of credit to one poster, Baby Finland, who dropped the name of a guy named Kevin Carson, a left-libertarian author who has radically shaped my beliefs over the last few years



--Dr. Quigley

#18
[account deactivated]
#19

In many ways I think Ayn Rand (and others) had the right of it.

We are alone in a godless universe. We can trust nobody to look out for our interests but ourselves. Furthermore, there are no real consequences to not behaving morally, because right and wrong are fictions. We are charged with making our own morality, and everybody is accountable for their own actions.

However, as a young white man who is lucky enough to be a part of a family with enough wealth that he never has to work a day in his life, why these observations lead so many to Libertarianism is beyond me. I am a social democrat for many reasons, but here's the main one:



i read this post up until there

#20

Don't get me wrong -- LF was an awesome forum in the beginning and it really opened my eyes to a lot of things I would never have seen otherwise. The effort-posts were absolutely phenomenal. The day-to-day commentary sucked, though, and got way worse after half the forum TOXX'ed themselves on the 2008 election. I learned a ton about the Congo Free State and Somalia and other things that American schools never teach, but when someone tried to argue that third world justice had prevailed in early 2009 and all U.S. soldiers were kicked out of Kyrgyzstan (and meanwhile I was reading from Kyrgyzstan as a soldier deploying to Afghanistan), I started to realize that a lot of people didn't know what the fuck they were talking about. The fact that they celebrated the death of a guy who literally died trying to render aid to Afghan truck drivers after an IED blast just further proved the point.

#21
[account deactivated]
#22

I swung way out to the left after I went to Uni. Again, I think a lot of that was just absorbing my environment. I went to a very liberal campus and started socializing more and making more friends, I ended up becoming more centrist on economic issues, a lot more for racial equality and affirmative action, more positive towards women's experiences, and learning more about religion and socializing witha broader spectrum of people sort of ruined positive atheism and antitheism for me (I kept on being a negative/weak atheist for some time afterward; I converted to Catholicism recently). I read LF a lot, and identified as something like an anarcho-communist for a while.

As an adult I've drifted more toward the center. In some ways the 2008 election caused me to lose respect for a lot of American liberals. A lot of the leftists I knew (including LF) were very pro-Obama, while genuine liberals like Kucinich (my own vote) got completely ignored. On top of that the identical-in-policy Clinton was completely trashed for "tearing the party apart". I don't know what that meant and I'm almost afraid to analyze it too much now, but it annoyed me a lot. I still consider myself a leftist but after that whole election I am not as passionate about it. I look at the people at Occupy Wallstreet or left-leaning people online with a lot more cynicism and I wish I didn't.

I still vote for leftist candidates (particularly on economic issues), and becoming a lot more religious means there is a lot more opportunity to get involved in charity work (which in turn helps redeem some of my faith in humanity to see the broad spectrum of people who get involved in helping others--left, right, libertarian, liberal, etc.). All I want is a compassionate society with some decent safety nets in place.

#23

Groulxsmith posted:

#24
[account deactivated]
#25
jesus christ

I smoked the odd joint with friends. I didn't like lager, I drank mild, like my granddad. More flavour. But they didn't sell Mild at the Labour Club rock night, so I'd nurse a pitcher of strongbow. They'd mark your hand at the door in permanent marker if you had ID, but the bar staff didn't check. We started to interpret poetry in school. I liked Philip Larkin, he was ambivalent about churches and disdainful of religion and hot on sex and that. Also William Blake. Back in those days, in Liverpool, going to the rock shows meant you were a "Goth". I ran with it. I smoked cloves and read weird books. I was going to be an English Teacher.

I went to university, I dropped out. I couldn't organise. I missed an entire semester's gender and rep lectures because I fucked up my timetable on the first day and nobody set me right. The lady at the dole asked me to drop out of "college" or they wouldn't pay me. I corrected her, "University." "College." "University". I dropped out. I was unemployed for a year, with some A levels and no work experience. I couldn't go to shows anymore. I just stayed at home, tossed off in front of the computer, and read as many books as came my way. Dawkins, Camus, Blake, Crowley, Lovecraft again, Illuminatus!, Bukowski. The "university bookstore", I guess, was a privately owned cooperative. It was left wing. "News from Nowhere," so I ended up reading Bakunin, Krotopkin, Marx, Engels also.

#26
from SSJ2 Goku Wilders classic City of God:

LF was a great catalyst for your personal political process because:
1) your views were scrutinized ruthlessly, whether you posted them or someone/something else was being made an example of;
2) there was a huge concentration of media being posted that showed the reality of capitalism, without the message being passed through any ideological filters;
3) effort posts;
4) namedropped authors or effort-introductions to concepts (there were multiple Reading Capital threads for instance).

LF was without a doubt the best subforum on SA and it was the reason I registered. It's silly to say that a subforum shaped your views, but it's true for many in this case. I don't recognize the attacks on it in this thread. For instance, the Obama thing: there were a lot of posters who were hoping he would become president simply for the ~* mAgic *~ of having a black president. His message and record were convincing. At the same time, the LF vanguard never stopped warning the masses that it was simply a case of one imperialist being replaced by another.

#27

noavbazzer posted:
jesus christ

I smoked the odd joint with friends. I didn't like lager, I drank mild, like my granddad. More flavour. But they didn't sell Mild at the Labour Club rock night, so I'd nurse a pitcher of strongbow. They'd mark your hand at the door in permanent marker if you had ID, but the bar staff didn't check. We started to interpret poetry in school. I liked Philip Larkin, he was ambivalent about churches and disdainful of religion and hot on sex and that. Also William Blake. Back in those days, in Liverpool, going to the rock shows meant you were a "Goth". I ran with it. I smoked cloves and read weird books. I was going to be an English Teacher.

I went to university, I dropped out. I couldn't organise. I missed an entire semester's gender and rep lectures because I fucked up my timetable on the first day and nobody set me right. The lady at the dole asked me to drop out of "college" or they wouldn't pay me. I corrected her, "University." "College." "University". I dropped out. I was unemployed for a year, with some A levels and no work experience. I couldn't go to shows anymore. I just stayed at home, tossed off in front of the computer, and read as many books as came my way. Dawkins, Camus, Blake, Crowley, Lovecraft again, Illuminatus!, Bukowski. The "university bookstore", I guess, was a privately owned cooperative. It was left wing. "News from Nowhere," so I ended up reading Bakunin, Krotopkin, Marx, Engels also.


i love that one

#28

noavbazzer posted:
jesus christ

I smoked the odd joint with friends. I didn't like lager, I drank mild, like my granddad. More flavour. But they didn't sell Mild at the Labour Club rock night, so I'd nurse a pitcher of strongbow. They'd mark your hand at the door in permanent marker if you had ID, but the bar staff didn't check. We started to interpret poetry in school. I liked Philip Larkin, he was ambivalent about churches and disdainful of religion and hot on sex and that. Also William Blake. Back in those days, in Liverpool, going to the rock shows meant you were a "Goth". I ran with it. I smoked cloves and read weird books. I was going to be an English Teacher.

I went to university, I dropped out. I couldn't organise. I missed an entire semester's gender and rep lectures because I fucked up my timetable on the first day and nobody set me right. The lady at the dole asked me to drop out of "college" or they wouldn't pay me. I corrected her, "University." "College." "University". I dropped out. I was unemployed for a year, with some A levels and no work experience. I couldn't go to shows anymore. I just stayed at home, tossed off in front of the computer, and read as many books as came my way. Dawkins, Camus, Blake, Crowley, Lovecraft again, Illuminatus!, Bukowski. The "university bookstore", I guess, was a privately owned cooperative. It was left wing. "News from Nowhere," so I ended up reading Bakunin, Krotopkin, Marx, Engels also.



please stop making fun of my posts

#29

I hate to go here, but I'd like you to know that my two best friends are gay, one out and one closeted. One's happy and one is miserable. I feel for them, both.
One of my parents' siblings has been in a committed relationship with another gay person (trying to be vague here so internet detectives won't cause trouble) for longer than I have been alive, that's over 40 years. I try to imagine being gay in the American midwest in the early 60's. I had enough problems in the 80's just dealing with the typical bullshit.

I'm no "kid," and I'm not naive.

Occupy is doing more than you will give credit for, and it will do more. I believe that with all my heart. Patience is a part of this.

#30
lol

Stalin decided the Comintern should instruct the communist parties that the social democrats were a bigger threat. Boy was he wrong! Fortunately, we don't have to deal with bullshit from the USSR fucking with the radical left like they did back then.

http://www.marxists.org/archive/trotsky/germany/

#31

babyfinland posted:
it haunts me that i probably turned like a hundred little kids into obnoxious trots via lf



lf truly made me veer completely to the right, especially wddp, and for that I am eternally grateful.

#32
http://forums.somethingawful.com/showthread.php?threadid=3468163

After Gaddafi's fall, the same militias which took him down have been raping, looting mosques, and killing black Libyans en masse...

Was anyone really foolish enough to predict otherwise? The ousting of Gaddafi is one of the most despicable charades I have ever seen; Gaddafi's Libya was a strong, secular, safe, and wealthy country, with the highest quality of life in all of Africa, free education, and free healthcare. There is absolutely zero evidence that Gaddafi's troops fired on unarmed protestors; fights did break out between the army and armed militias, but they are a far cry from simple protestors.

And the prison that was supposed to have been the site of a mass murder committed by Gaddafi soldiers?

The bones found on the scene belonged to animals. It, too, was a complete farce...

These armed terrorist gangs do not have the support of the Libyan people, and the only way they won the "civil war" was through the support of NATO.

There are rumors of a resurgent pro-Gaddafi movement to restore the Jamahiriya. Its success is doubtful with Gaddafi dead, but any attempt to overthrow this treasonous anarchic psuedo-state is welcomed by me at least....

(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)


#33
looooll
#34
[account deactivated]
#35
[account deactivated]
#36

Brown Moses are you a Libyan or are you just very informed? I'm genuinely curious.

#37

pogfan1996 posted:

Brown Moses are you a Libyan or are you just very informed? I'm genuinely curious.



leave me alone man im trying to figure out what angle to go at when i get him to probate me

#38
[account deactivated]
#39
mm brown molasses
#40

noavbazzer posted:
Think about what life means for a teenage girl in a tiny village in Hebei. Wouldn't assembling iPads for 12 hours a day actually seem a lot better?