anyways i read the art of loving and it was very useful for me, because i am bad at it. also its really short. other than that i don't know anything about the guy, but he must be nice and loving.
laika posted:started reading After Finitude if anyone wants to talk about it
haven't touched it but I'm glad you're still kickin it in the rhizzone DM
roseweird posted:but it sounds like he has couched it in a combination of bad science (physical "laws" are Really Laws, rather than parts of a coherent physical theory) and bad theology (god is gone but might come back?), in a way that sounds very misleading.
he doesn't suggest either of these things. you should probably read some words he wrote
i have no idea why you think he is presenting his ideas as novelty when his work is explicitly an engagement with kant and hume. his thought on contingency is a direct return to hume and his conceptualizing of the problem of inductive reasoning, positioned against kantian currents in contemporary critical theory. he is very clear about this. i do not know why this gives you an idea that he believes he is revolutionizing philosophical thought. NoFreeWill isn't particularly helping here but you should probably read the words he actually wrote, instead of a fawning little introductory piece for the new inquiry i linked to give you a vague idea of who he is, before denouncing him as a charlatan
e: actually yeah NoFreeWill is just being dumb here he should probably actually read meillassoux too, don't let this guys weird impressions sour you on him roseweird he is worth a read
Edited by blinkandwheeze ()
roseweird posted:what are you trying to say, gravity might "stop working"??? like, fire might stop burning? the moon might fall down to earth? god might smite the cedars of lebanon and the city of babylon? yeah, no shit?
gravity isn't a "law" in any meaningful sense except within a limited physical theory that treats it as a law for predictive purposes, which doesn't render rationalism "idiotic", it just makes it limited to the realm of reason... gravity was never a law of the universe, only a law of human perception of th euniverse. gravity is a physical phenomenon arising from relations between other physical phenomena, and it's insane to suggest we shouldn't epect physical phenomena to behave rationally. sure, everything we know is contingent, but i don't see what is so astounding about this observation, it is what the ancients felt when they perceived that god sustains all reality, and that everything that exists exists only by god's grace. so far, every day the sun has risen, but perhaps tomorrow... it will not? well, say your prayers.
seriously how far gone do you have to be that you want to read a book because you agree with it that gravity might suddenly stop working. holy shit.
Uh, gravity isn't real
wasted posted:I don't get why Ken's characters prefer suicide (figuratively or otherwise) by jumping. I'm sure they have knives, ropes and petrol in the United Kingdom.
its a personal fixation lol
Also, if gravity suddenly stopped working, you can expect lazy scientists to posit that a whole bunch of matter was destroyed rather than question their theoretical assumptions. Dark matter pfftt.
deadken posted:its a personal fixation lol
do us all a favor and try it out firsthand imo. wanker.
EmanuelaOrlandi posted:deadken posted:its a personal fixation lol
do us all a favor and try it out firsthand imo. wanker.
rude
caprimulgus posted:swirlsofhistory are you an elaborate troll or a simple idiot
Why don't you ask your mom
babyhueypnewton posted:haven't touched it but I'm glad you're still kickin it in the rhizzone DM
thanks
This post gets at two important issues that the left is going to have to grapple with to be successful: (student) debt and social media.
stegosaurus posted:I'm reading the first sentence of the first comment to an article on the north star called "why is there still no socialist party in the US." here is that sentence:
This post gets at two important issues that the left is going to have to grapple with to be successful: (student) debt and social media.
update: just finished this. it was cray.